Fancy Strawberry Cafe

101 N Mill St, New Castle, PA 16101, United States
+1 724-504-0698
$$$ Cafe , Coffee shop , Ice cream shop , Sandwich shop
(36 Reviews)
Price Range $1–10

Welcome to Fancy Strawberry Cafe, a delightful café nestled in New Castle, PA, at 101 N Mill St. With a charming strawberry theme that evokes nostalgia and warmth, this local gem has quickly become a favorite for coffee lovers and casual diners alike. The phone number for any inquiries or orders is +1 724-504-0698.

Step inside, and you are greeted by a bright and inviting atmosphere that perfectly combines cute decor with a sense of community. The interior, reminiscent of early 2000s Strawberry Shortcake vibes, offers comfortable seating, beautiful windows, and a cozy dining area that encourages you to relax and enjoy your time.

Fancy Strawberry Cafe prides itself on serving an array of enticing drinks and snacks, making it a versatile spot for breakfast, lunch, or a sweet afternoon treat. Among the delicious offerings, you'll find an exciting selection of Boba drinks, such as the Lemonade Boba, Milk Tea Boba, Matcha Tea Boba, and Cold Brew Boba, all priced at a delightful US$5.25. Each of these drinks is crafted with care and bursting with flavor, making them perfect companions for a leisurely afternoon.

The café also hosts a Wednesday Soup Special, offering a warming cup of homemade soup for just US$3.50 or a generous bowl with a roll for US$5.50. Don't forget to grab a roll for only US$0.99! It's comfort food at its finest, ideal for those chilly days or when you simply need a cozy meal.

For those with a sweet tooth, Fancy Strawberry Cafe offers Chocolate Covered Items by Pre-Order, including delightful Cake Pops at US$4.50 and rich Fudge for US$3.50. These treats add a special touch to any visit, making them perfect for celebrations or just a little indulgence.

The positive vibes are palpable, as captured in the heartfelt reviews from patrons. Gillian Hall describes it as “a cute strawberry-themed café with nice local vibes.” She was particularly impressed by the freshness of her meal and the sweet refreshment of her strawberry-hazelnut iced coffee. Similarly, Brady Lego raved about the freshly baked muffins and the incredible “the uge” latte, emphasizing the café's perfect balance of sweetness and quality.

Many customers have come to cherish Fancy Strawberry Cafe not only for its excellent coffee but also for the welcoming and friendly service. Zane Barger mentioned a delightful diverse drink menu that breaks away from the mundane, highlighting the staff's knowledge and readiness to recommend the best options. Meanwhile, Xam Theprod feels at home here, calling it his "go-to coffee and ice cream spot," praising the authentic love and joy the staff impart to every customer.

Whether you’re in the mood for a refreshing boba, a hearty soup, or a sweet treat, Fancy Strawberry Cafe is a must-visit. The perfect blend of delightful drinks, cozy ambiance, and friendly staff will surely leave you wanting to return for more. Make it your next stopping point in New Castle, where community spirit meets delicious offerings!

Service options
Takeaway
Dine-in
Delivery
Highlights
Great coffee
Great tea selection
Popular for
Breakfast
Solo dining
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Offerings
Coffee
Quick bite
Dining options
Dessert
Atmosphere
Casual
Crowd
Tourists
Payments
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot
Parking
Openings Hours
Checking

Monday

08:00 AM - 06:00 PM

Tuesday

08:00 AM - 06:00 PM

Wednesday

08:00 AM - 06:00 PM

Thursday

08:00 AM - 06:00 PM

Friday

08:00 AM - 07:00 PM

Saturday

Closed

Sunday

Closed

36 Reviews
Gillian Hall

21 Sep 2025

A cute strawberry-themee cafe with nice local vibes. The staff are friendly, and the tomato blossom that I had was incredibly fresh. The strawberry-hazelnut iced coffee I had was sweet and refreshing too. Definitely will be back again in a few weeks after my next dentist appointment lol

Dippy Fresh

08 Sep 2025

Wonderful place!!! My matcha boba was delicious and sweet, there were high-quality games to borrow, and the employees were super friendly and knew just what to recommend us. We'll be visiting again hopefully!

Frankie Bennett

14 Aug 2025

My boyfriend and I have started coming here recently, and our third visit basically confirmed that it was our new spot! I should’ve taken more photos because this place has a cute little dining room area and beautiful windows to sit in front of The staff is friendly and welcoming, and the atmosphere is bright and nostalgic. Think something like early 2000s Strawberry Shortcake vibes The food (especially the baked goods), you can tell is made with care and a lot of thought behind the recipes. I’ve tried the ice cream, and they have so many tasty and sweet choices for toppings that you’ll be able to try out a ton of different combos. The drinks have some variety too; different styles of coffees and mochas, boba tea and milk (my favorites!!). They also have this unique drink called Joba Boba, that I tried recently. It’s like a soda pop boba/float drink, and it was AMAZING, I didn’t realize how fast I drank it We will for sure be back, and I’m planning on showing my best friend this place as well! I can’t recommend this place enough, thank you for bringing a spot like this to New Castle

Brady Lego

07 Jul 2025

Great coffee!! I recommend getting their muffins they are baked fresh!! Their “the uge” latte is amazing!! Perfectly sweet coffee a great environment and vibe to the store!! I seriously recommend popping in for a bite to eat for breakfast, lunch, or dessert!

Sadie Sheldone

23 Jun 2025

Recently moved to New Castle and I wanted to find a good place to get coffee. I tried a few places like Joseph's and the local restaraunts but Fancy Strawberry ended my search. This is the best coffee in town for the best price and everyone working there is kind and wonderful. Highly reccomend if you love coffee and conversation

Mary Church

23 Jun 2025

My coffee was so delicious and the lady was so nice. I'm going back for lunch with my friend and the all you can eat ice cream for $5 o Friday is more than a deal. Cute cozy great vibes.

Zane Barger

15 Jun 2025

I went here for the first time today and loved it! The coffee is excellent, the staff are super friendly, and the interior has a lovely design. And I love that they have a diverse menu of drinks, not just boring lattes - they've got stuff I don't normally see around here, like breves and Boba. Thank you, I will definitely be back!

Xam Theprod

01 Jun 2025

When I first found this place I had been looking for a spot to great coffee, not only did I find what I was looking for I was blessed meeting what I call now Family! The Fancy strawberry is now my go to coffee and ice cream spot for the nieces and nephews when they come in town! These people love to put a smile on the face of customers and show the love of God thick and through to all who come!

Join the Fancy Strawberry Cafe Newsletter

Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.